Friday, October 11, 2013

in 1492...

I'm sure you know the rest.

As I sit here, feet kicked up on this lovely start to Columbus Day weekend, I'm fondly remembering grade school.  Columbus Day wasn't just a day off--it was an event, a week-long celebration of everything explorer, an excuse for half the class to dress like Native Americans and for our teachers to throw us into make-shift canoes in the middle of the classroom.  Okay, maybe that was just my school, but for years, I blindly followed my teachers into believing Christopher Columbus was a hero.

Then I grew up, the world became more cynical, and I read Howard Zinn's People's History of the United States.  I would never again look at good ol' Chrissy the same.  Never heard of it?  Here's an excerpt:
Zinn . (You may stop on page 8, but continue if you'd like).

Today, I read this and thought, "Maybe I've been wrong to be angry for so long.  Maybe there's still something heroic left in the story of Christopher Columbus."

So what do you think?  Should we celebrate Columbus Day?  (And you know what I mean--there are no Columbus parties on my block, either.  I mean as a holiday.  Official.  On the calendar.)  Are there any other national holidays you find offensive?  Worthless?  Do you appreciate anything about today besides your lack of alarm clock?

Jot down some answers in the comment section below, use your best English skills, and be ready to discuss.  Tuesday.  No excuses.

And this Columbus Day, do what is expected in his honor: let's walk into someone's house and tell them we live there now.

Haha.  I think...



38 comments:

  1. Bryan Marengo
    10/11/13
    Honors English


    Christopher Columbus was an evil man, but that doesn’t mean that he wasn’t misunderstood by Howard Zinn. There is nothing that sets Columbus apart from George Washington, Franklin Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, Andrew Jackson, or Jesus. What do the five people that I just mentioned and Christopher Columbus have in common? All of them were, and are still, loved by large groups of people. But they were also racists. People call George Washington a good man, general, and father of our country, yet many people are unaware that 316 slaves lived on Mount Vernon, George Washington’s home. Franklin Roosevelt, the man that helped defeat Hitler, a person that let his racist views result in millions of deaths, suffered from anti-Japanese hysteria and had thousands of Japanese Americans thrown into camps in the United States. Woodrow Wilson, the man that presided over the U.S. during World War I, was prejudice against people with low IQ’s and Africans. Andrew Jackson is famous for being racist, yet he is still loved by many people today and included in the top ten of many surveys that ask people who the greatest president was (Washington, Roosevelt, and Wilson are also usually included in the top ten). Jesus is one of the most famous people that has ever lived, the most popular religion includes him in the Bible, yet the Bible’s hint of Jesus’ racism is often overlooked. The Bible’s text tells of a lady that begs Jesus for food, it says, “"I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel." [said Jesus] The woman came and knelt before him. "Lord, help me!" she said. He replied, "It is not right to take the children's bread and toss it to their dogs."” He called the lady a dog because of her race (earlier in the text it explains that she was a Canaanite woman). But that doesn’t stop people of all races from admiring who Jesus was. It doesn’t stop them from admiring George Washington, Franklin Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, or Andrew Jackson either, so why should Christopher Columbus be hated for being racist?
    Howard Zinn’s argument was basically, “Christopher Columbus’ actions prove that he is racist.” This implies that Zinn didn’t think that Columbus Day should be a holiday, but I don’t see anything wrong with it being one. Racism doesn’t stop people from celebrating President’s Day (at least fifteen presidents were racist) or Flag Day (a day celebrating the flag of a country that was founded on racism; “We the people” didn’t apply to blacks.) Columbus Day should be celebrated; it is the only day of the year where we can appreciate a man re-rediscovering a continent; the fact that he was racist shouldn’t interfere with his “discovery”.
    The only holiday that I find offensive (other than every religious holiday in existence) is Martin Luther King Jr. Day. I can explain why I find this holiday offensive by the use of questions: Where is Malcolm X Day? Where is Susan B. Anthony Day? Where is John Locke Day? Malcolm X was another African American civil rights activist; Susan B. Anthony was a women’s rights activist; John Locke was one of the first people to believe that all men are created equal. Martin Luther King Jr. gets a holiday while those people don’t. Why?

    ReplyDelete
  2. We never really went into detail on Christopher Columbus. I remember coloring him in on Columbus Day in the first grade. And we’ve all seen the Mini Wheats commercial when the cereal is talking to the kid about, “Columbus sailed the ocean blue, in 1492,” but that’s about it. However, Columbus Day an insignificant day? Columbus wasn’t the first person here, those were the Native Americans. He also named the Native Americans ‘Indians’, because isn’t that where he thought he was? Asia? I don’t know the background Christopher Columbus came from, and I don’t know if he was good at geography and got an A+ in it on his report card. If he was still alive today, he’d probably feel real stupid; everyone is tarnishing his name and bashing his holiday. Anyway, just because Christopher Columbus died as dim as a broken light bulb doesn’t mean he should get a pity day. We can keep it on the calendar though. At least his ‘discovery’ benefits tens of millions of students every year.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Christopher Columbus isn’t who we think he is. He didn’t graciously sail to America with his 3 ships and then made friends with the Native Americans as they pass around the Thanksgiving turkey. Christopher Columbus who was perceived as a hero was actually a man that was conceited and heartless. After being welcomed by the kindhearted “Indians” he betrayed them, captured them and by 1508 over 3 million of them had died in war, slavery, mines, abuse and over working. After the genocide that Christopher Columbus committed, he most definitely doesn’t deserve a holiday. Even though there are countless of other well-known people in history that have practiced slavery and genocide, Christopher Columbus still shouldn’t be honored for his corrupt ways and maybe those people shouldn’t be either. Along with Columbus Day, thanksgiving is another worthless holiday. Now that we know Columbus slowly wiped out the Native American population, we know that he never once came together with them and had a feast. There is nothing I appreciate about Columbus Day besides the fact that America was discovered and I can sleep in. Columbus Day isn’t a day to celebrate; it is a day to be ashamed of.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Khadijah Coleman
    Mrs. Rock
    Period 11
    October 12, 2013

    And I Thought You Were a Hero

    Every second Monday in the month of October we celebrate Columbus Day. Columbus Day is to signify the success of Christopher Columbus for discovering “Asia” or the “New World” (unfortunately for him he didn’t land in Asia). Even though Columbus technically never made it to his desired location, the discovery of the “New World” made a greater impact on the world than that of Leif Erickson. In kindergarten we are told stories about the great Christopher Columbus and his adventure to America. We celebrated him, we drew pictures of him, and we even sang songs and poems about Christopher’s voyage. In fourteen hundred ninety-two Columbus sailed the ocean blue and all that jazz. I celebrated Columbus and his accomplishments, but what teachers of the past failed to tell me was what happened after the voyage. And just a few minutes ago I found out and now my image on Columbus being a hero is nothing but shattered glass.

    Going back to when I was younger I remember repeating to my mother over and over again about the things I learned about Christopher Columbus and how great he was. She would tell me there was more to Columbus that I didn’t know and that he really didn’t discover anything. She was right, the Vikings discovered America way before Columbus did. And when he did come to America his encounter with the natives were much darker than what the movies I watched depicted. Instead of greeting them with kindness he took them aboard his ship as prisoners and forced them to find gold.

    The term genocide is used as a way to describe how Columbus treated the natives. In chapter one of “Columbus, The Indians and Human Progress” Columbus clearly believed that the Arawak tribe was inferior. He wrote in his journal that they could make fine servants and that they were naïve only because they offered to share and trade their possessions with Columbus. The natives had no idea that Columbus was hell bent on finding gold and that they were soon going to be slaves sold to the highest bidder. Many of the natives died in captivity or on the job finding gold (natives had their hand cut off and bled to death if they didn’t bring enough gold).Those who tried to escape were hunted down and killed, in two years 250,000 natives were dead.

    What disturbs me more is that there are countless other explorers like Columbus that treated the natives with the same if not even more hostility. When Cortés came to Mexico the natives thought he was an Aztec man-god. Just like Columbus Cortés was looking for gold and in doing so he began a march of death, destroying the Aztec empire and killing Montezuma leaving the Aztecs in the hands of the Spaniards. The Puritans who were very strict Christians killed natives believing that God wanted them to kill the “heathens” in order to get their land. Even the pilgrims killed the same Native Americans that helped them when they were at their weakest. Proving that Thanksgiving is yet another holiday celebrating the downfall of the natives.

    The past is an abyss and there is but so much we can try and understand about it. History back then was told by the point of view of the white male, not by women and not by slaves. The natives have suffered a great loss for several generations all because of one man. You could argue that morals were different back then. You could also argue how there are world leaders from the past and present we celebrate that were as racist as Columbus. I can however guarantee you that what Columbus did wasn’t racism it was genocide. Hitler was infamous for genocide against Jews and you don’t see people celebrating him, what was so different about what Columbus did?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was honestly shocked when I read this. Yeah I knew Christopher Columbus was an awful dude but I didn’t know how awful he truly was. We should, however, still have a holiday. Not named for Chrissy though because he most certainly doesn’t deserve to be celebrated. We all are shoved down our throats at a very young age that Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue and accidentally found the Americas. He greeted the Indians and they became friends. That was the gist of it… nothing more. But in reality, he was a cold- hearted asshole who cared for nothing more than how much his profit was. If the Indians were in his way, he was going to kill them. In two years, through murder, mutilation, or suicide, HALF of the 250,000 Indians on Haiti we’re dead. Only two years it took. Not to mention, in 1495 he went and collected as many as 1,500 Arawak men, women, and children, put them into pens that were guarded by Spaniards and vicious dogs and picked out 500 of what he considered the “best” slaves to be transported back to Spain. Simply, Christopher Columbus was not made out to what we were thought to believe. He was a heartless man, who was selfish, and did not care about the open-armed Indians.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Everyone knows “Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue, in 1492” because that’s all we have ever learned. However after reading these two articles my perspective has changed drastically on Mr. Columbus and the Holiday itself. First of all he never even found what he was intending to find! Then when he did find land he lied about finding it first for money, “Then, on October 12, a sailor named Rodrigo saw the early morning moon shining on white sands, and cried out. It was an island in the Bahamas, the Caribbean sea. The first man to sight land was supposed to get a yearly pension of 10,000 maravedis for life, but Rodrigo never got it. Columbus claimed he had seen a light the evening before. He got the reward.” Additionally, Columbus not only had no clue where he was he also lied to the Court in Madrid, “Columbus’s report to the Court in Madrid was extravagant. He insisted he had reached Asia (it was Cuba) and an island off the coast of China (Hisponiola). His description was part fact, part fiction.” I also find Columbus day stupid and worthless. Although many will say he helped discover America they are just as wrong as Columbus, “So, approaching land, they were met by the Arawak Indians, who swam out to greet them. The Arawaks lived in village communes, had a developed agriculture of corn, yams, cassava.” During my earlier years of school all we were told was that Christopher Columbus discovered America in 1492 and that was it, teachers did not go into detail therefore I was not aware of the terrible things that Columbus and his “soldiers /people” did to the natives, “At one part of the island he got into a fight with Indians who refused to trade as many bows and arrows as he and his men wanted. Two were run through with swords and bled to death.” Also the actions that Columbus’s men took were horrid, “Because of Columbus’s exaggerated report and promises, his second expedition was given seventeen ships and more than twelve hundred men. The aim was clear: slaves and gold. They went from island to island in the Caribbean, taking Indians as captives. But as word spread of the Europeans’ intent they found more and more empty villages. On Haiti, they found that the sailors left behind at Fort Navidad had been killed in a battle with the Indians, after they had roamed the island in gangs looking for gold, taking women and children as slaves for sex and labor.” and Columbus’s mean did horrid things the children, “Total control led to total cruelty. The Spaniards ‘thought nothing of knifing Indians by tens and twenties and of cutting slices off them to test the sharpness of their blades.’ Las Casas tells how ‘two of these so-called Christians met two Indian boys one day, each carrying a parrot’ they took the parrots and for fun beheaded the boys.’ Overall I now think we shouldn’t get this day off and many other schools even nearby don’t. Other holidays I find aren’t worthless but the things we do on those days do make sense. For example although I can’t complain, but we get presents on Jesus’s birthday. I know I don’t get presents on my father’s birthday. Another holiday that throws me off is how do we get candy and toys on Easter, when we are supposed to be celebrating when Jesus became resurrected from the dead. In the end, the only other thing I appreciate about Columbus Day other than the fact I don’t have to wake up at 5:20 Monday morning is that I also get an extra day to catch up on all my work, relax, and I am happy that America was discovered weather it be by the Arawaks or Columbus.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh wow. I guess this explains why there aren’t many Native Americans today (credits to Chrissy Columbus for killing half of them). Who would’ve thought, the words “Columbus” and “jerk” fit so well together! Literally, he hasn’t even been in the “new world” for five minutes and the first thing he thinks about is, “Where is the gold?” Not even a hello to the Indians or anything. How rude! I would at least offer them tea or something. Not only did he invade their territory, but he also made the Indians do his dirty work, and if they didn’t, he’d kill them! Isn’t that sad? Our “hero” took credit for finding the land (poor Rodrigo), killed and captured Indians for his own good, and even lied to the King and Queen. Ladies and gentlemen, Columbus has played us all. As stated in the reading, “One can lie outright about the past. Or one can omit facts which might lead to unacceptable conclusions.” Now, I’m not saying Columbus is ENTIRELY a bad person; many other explorers have done the same thing. It’s just the fact that I grew up learning how great Columbus was for trying and stuff, I never knew what a selfish man he really was.

    To be honest, I never understood the reason for “Columbus Day”. As Roy Crazy Horse puts it, “Why celebrate a man who started looking for India and landed in the Caribbean, who never put down his foot in the United States, who brought slavery to this continent?” I don’t know about Columbus, but I sure wouldn’t want a holiday dedicated to my failure. At least I get to sleep in that day though! That’s always good. Other than that, there’s really no reason to keep Columbus Day on the calendar. It’s kind of like Groundhogs Day. I know we don’t get off on that holiday, but what’s the whole point of it though? We live in the twenty-first century. I’m pretty sure we don’t need a groundhog to predict our weather for the next six weeks. Nothing makes sense anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  10. We can all agree that after reading Howard Zinn's People's History of the United States, you feel like you found out batman was an evil villain stealing from the children of Gotham City. A hero that wasn’t a hero. But, I thought about it and realized this Columbus dude wasn’t that bad of a guy. Think about the time period and compare to today. At the time, Europe was huge on slaves and other riches. This was normal. So, how can you expect Christopher Columbus to be any different? I don’t agree on what Columbus did, but I understand why. Honestly, I think Christopher Columbus is actually pretty intelligent. He knew how to control these people and
    how to get the most out of them. I know Columbus also gave a lot of Native Americans illnesses, but it isn’t like he meant to. Who walks into a country and goes, “I’m now going to kill you all by passing illnesses from you that I didn’t even know I could pass.”? Now, Columbus might have brought slavery to this country, but it was bound to happen. Sooner or later, if Columbus didn’t come, someone else would have discovered America. Since Europe and other places including Egypt and Asia already had slaves, this idea would travel to America somehow.
    Many say Columbus Day shouldn’t be celebrated because Columbus didn’t actually discover America, but if Columbus didn’t step foot onto America it would have been a while before someone did. When Columbus sailed the ocean blue is how America was found. When the rest of the world and America became a whole. It’s a day that should be celebrated because there is a possibility that you could still be a Native American. I appreciate that Columbus gave us America.
    Holidays are great not only because Sleep and I are married, but because celebrating and parties are fun. Although, there is one holiday that irks me the most. Easter. I’m buddhist and never celebrated Easter a day in my life by choice, but the idea was forced on me. At least, during Christmas other religious holidays are spent during this time, but not during Easter. As a kid, I still had to do egg hunts and color in bunnies with a purple crayon and celebrate a holiday I don’t believe in. I don’t care if a chocolate bunny in a plastic egg has nothing to do with Easter, it was still called Easter Egg Hunt. The idea of Easter was still there.
    There are some holidays I find completely useless. Mother’s Day and Father’s Day is on the top. It’s not like I don’t love my parents but the appreciation and love kids lavish their parents with on one day should be all year, everyday of their life not just 24 hours. Lastly, Valentine’s Day is dumb. Especially because I feel lonelier on a day that should be filled with love.

    ReplyDelete
  11. There's something after reading this that made me really mad. When I was younger and I learned about Christopher Columbus, I thought he was a pretty cool person. That's how everybody makes him out to be anyways. He was a gold digger.... Even though he founded America, we shouldn't have a hoilday named after a jerk. It's like having a hoilday named after the devil or something. He almost got rid of all the Native Americans and it's really hard to find someone that is a Native American today. Nobody really celebrates Columbus day anyways. We just like it because it's a day off from school. Who cares about Columbus? Just because he supposedly discovered our country, he's this amazing person that should be praised. He was so dumb that he called the Americans, Indians... Well.. they obviously don't look like Indians. Maybe one thing that was actually important that he found out was that the world is round not flat.. but that doesn't change the fact that there shouldn't be a hoilday is his honor.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sorry for some of the other readers out there who took this to the heart, but newsflash: If it wasn't Columbus, someone else would've terrorized just the same. It was common of the era. Cortes did it, Pizarro did it, it was a trend. These men came with a mission with mind. There happened to be some natives in their way, and they had to work around it. Obviously, I don't approve of genocide, and what they did wasn't okay. Their directions didn't include a humanity clause in it; only what was valuable to bring back. We can't do anything to help the Arawaks, so it's not something I would get mad over.
    However, I do want to suggest that we stop lying to kids. First, they have to deal with the whole Santa Claus thing, and now this hero commited these disgusting crimes? No more blashphemy; all kids need to know was that Columbus sailed from Spain to the Americas expecting India. He mistakingly called them Indians and it has stuck ever since.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Christopher Columbus was not a "great explorer" who found the "new world". He didn't just graciously take it over. Christopher Columbus was a man in search of wealth and power who enslaved thousands upon thousands of indigenous people. Suicide rates spiked to an all time high, the amount of work the poor Arawak people were put through was excruciating. Many woman were used solely for sexual favors, and they often drowned their children so they did not have to suffer like they did. Not only this, but his men brutally slaughtered almost the entire population. Even children were murdered. As it says in the text, two boys were playing with a parrot, and Columbus's men took the parrot and beheaded the boys for fun. No Columbus does not deserve a holiday, that second article did not convince me otherwise. Hitler doesn't get a holiday, so why should Columbus?

    ReplyDelete
  14. We all learned about Crusty Columbus when we were little. We all sang the annoying rhyme, colored in the little “Indians” and went home to tell our parents that he was a hero. Except no one tells second graders that in 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue, and then he killed thousands of people. Columbus wiped out an entire Native American tribe, lied to his king and queen, and was a selfish and power-hungry douche. Yes, those things are terrible. But we have to accept the fact that if it wasn’t him, then it would’ve been somebody else anyway.
    During this time period, slavery in Europe was a common occurrence, and everyone wanted gold. “People’s History of the United States” says, “The Arawaks of the Bahama Islands… were remarkable… for their hospitality. These traits did not stand out in the Europe of the Renaissance, dominated as it was by… the frenzy for money…” So although what Columbus did was inexcusable, Europe benefited from it. Furthermore, Columbus writes in his journal, “As soon as I arrived in the Indies… I took some of the natives by force in order that they might learn and might give me information…” He kidnapped natives, but he did that because they were resources to him. Columbus needed to use them in order to find gold. If Columbus hadn’t done what he did, then everything would be different. Who knows, maybe none of us would be living in America right now.
    Clearly, Crusty Columbus was a man with a mission. His journey didn’t involve a rule about being nice to the Indians. He needed to find what was valuable, and bring it back to his nation. His clear vision was what allowed him to accomplish his task. So while I don’t support genocide, Christopher Columbus did what he needed to do as a messenger. But should we have a holiday for him? I don’t think so. He doesn’t deserve his own holiday for killing people! Because he killed people, he gained riches during his lifetime. If anything, that’s all he should have. Another holiday that I don’t think should be celebrated is Valentine’s Day. You should love and cherish the important people in your life every day, not just on February 14th.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Columbus obviously was a bad dude but isn’t everyone at some time or another? Whether it’s physically or verbally everyone harms someone else and that’s how things get done. In Micheal Skubes’ article “You Say You Want a Revolution” he states that only the rock throwing kind of people get things done. Well Christopher Columbus was a rock thrower and… he got stuff done. If he didn’t accidentally stumble on the Americas then we wouldn’t be here today because most people still thought we would fall off the edge of the Earth. He proved that theory wrong and more people came over after him.
    Even though he wasn’t the first or second person to come to the Americas he is still pretty important but he doesn’t deserve a holiday. For example the Vikings came over to the Americas long before Christy Columbus and we don’t even know about Leaf Erickson day even though it’s on October 9th. Erickson and his crew were the first Europeans to come over to the Americas so they should have the official holiday, not Columbus. Columbus Day is the only holiday that aggravates me but we won’t get rid of it because people aren’t up for change. This Columbus Day and Columbus days to come; I just look forward to sleeping in and a day off from school.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Every child knows “Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492”, because it’s all we ever learned growing up. We all sang those annoying songs, colored in a gazillion pictures, and dressed up as what we thought was a “Hero”. Yet, no one told us the truth behind Christopher Columbus. In reality Columbus was a very selfish man who cared for nothing more than his own profit. He also wiped out an entire Native American tribe, and lied to the king and queen about his discovery. Although it sounds terrible, we must accept the fact that if it wasn’t him, it would have been someone else.
    During this time period, everyone wanted gold. Which explains why Christopher Columbus did what he did. Of course, after seeing the Arawaks with the gold accessories, it opened up the opportunity for Christopher to get his hands on the gold first. And although, what he did was unacceptable, Europe still benefitted from it. Moreover, Christopher wrote in his journal,” As soon as I arrived in the Indies, I took some of the Natives by force in order that they might give me information…” Maybe holding the natives captive was a little over-the-top, but in the end “You got to do what you got to do.”And if it weren’t for Columbus where would we be today? ...I guess we’ll never know.
    Although Columbus wasn’t the greatest, he was still pretty important…just not important enough to have a holiday. For instance, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. He was a very inspirational and intelligent man that made a huge impact on our society today. And no I’m not just saying this because I am an African American, but because he was actually someone who earned and deserved his place. Therefore, we celebrate his importance on the third Monday of January. But a holiday shouldn’t be wasted on Columbus; just the fact that he is remembered and has a place in history today should be enough.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not instigating
      Janet Lam Wrote:
      I’m not complaining about the fact that we celebrate Columbus Day, but the holiday is complete garbage. Christopher did absolutely nothing to deserve the honor of having his own national holiday, which by the way, the same privilege is also given to a man who goes by the name of Martin Luther King Jr.

      Delete
  18. When I was younger most kids, including myself, believed that Christopher Columbus was a hero. Now growing up and ready different articles I've came to the conclusion that he is far from a hero and closer to a jerk. Christopher basically sailed to someone else's land and just took over. The native Americans were so nice to him, greeting him right away and offering him anything he needed. Christopher probably didn't even say hi, he probably started commanding at the people. He took kids probably my age and woman for sex which is beyond horrible and took others for help to find gold. Once he couldn't find anymore gold he decided to kill some of them. What did any of these people do to deserve that? Columbus didn't even discover anything because native Americans were already on that land. I don't celebrate this day at all. What is there to celebrate? Exactly. Nothing. What are we going to do? Have a barbecue for Columbus. No, that's far from what he deserves. All I know is that I get to seep in on this day. For all I know we should be remembering the native Americans that were treated horribly rather than getting a day off for Columbus.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Christopher Columbus was an awful man motivated by greed, and nothing could possibly justify his actions. He stole the credit of finding an island from Rodrigo, lied to the king and queen of Spain, and killed millions of the natives. Many people will try to argue that Columbus was just like the rest of the men in Europe, and if he didn't discover America, then someone else would have done what he did. They say that many people moved to America and discovered that the world wasn’t flat because of him. But that’s not true! The concept that people in that time period thought that the world was flat is completely false; everybody with an education knew that Earth was round – the ancient Greeks proved the fact more than 2,000 years ago before Columbus was even born. He never stepped foot in North America either; Columbus landed in the Bahamas. Also, did no one else read the part about Las Casas? He started out just like Christopher Columbus. Las Casas was a European man who traveled to the New World where he owned a plantation with slaves. However, unlike the heinous Columbus, he saw the cruelty in the way the natives were being treated and changed his ways. He became a priest and stood against the cruelty of the Spaniards. If Las Casas, a fellow European, could see how wrong the way he treated the native people was, then why couldn’t Christopher Columbus? I’m not complaining about the fact that we celebrate Columbus Day, but the holiday is complete garbage. Christopher did absolutely nothing to deserve the honor of having his own national holiday, which by the way, the same privilege is also given to a man who goes by the name of Martin Luther King Jr.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Im instigating
      Kayla Hamler Wrote: Although Columbus wasn’t the greatest, he was still pretty important…just not important enough to have a holiday. For instance, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. He was a very inspirational and intelligent man that made a huge impact on our society today. And no I’m not just saying this because I am an African American, but because he was actually someone who earned and deserved his place.

      Delete
  20. Christopher is not a hero, or a villain, he is a person. He is a person that made a big impact on history. Columbus was the first to truly connect the western world and the Americas. He was a genius, expert sailor, and was willing to push the envelope. That is what we honor him for. Columbus was also greedy, brought the slave market, and was overly cruel to the Natives. That is what we condemn him for. In my opinion, We should still have Columbus day, but not to celebrate the man, but the historical achievements he made. And while we celebrate this day, we should educate ourselves on both sides of the coin, remembering both the great achievements, and the horrible atrocities of Columbus. While remembering the atrocities, we need to keep in mind the time he was in. The morality of the 21st century is a lot different than the morality of 15th, and what he did wasn't that bad for the time. So we should celebrate, but with a grain of salt.

    ReplyDelete
  21. When I grew up, Christopher Columbus was said out to be a great man who did many “great things” which was all misunderstood. Christopher Columbus was greeted by the Arawaks who were vulnerable and accepting that this man came onto their territory. How did Columbus just take over and commit outrageous actions? Slowly the natives were dying, either suicide or hard labor. By the year 1615, there was none of the original Arawaks left on the island. There should be no credit given to a man who costed so many lives not even to mention he didn’t even discover the Americas first. His mindset was gold and he didn’t care what he had to do to all these innocent people. Families murdered their own infants because they scared of what they had to go through. It makes me angry that we honor someone who took advantage of someone’s kindness. We should not have a day off to celebrate Christopher Columbus, even though we do like the day off it isn't fair considering what he did. I really don’t understand why we celebrate Halloween. Like is it supposed to be kind to hand out free candy but to be scared doing it? Other than that, I understand holidays for the most part of it.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Columbus Day never really had an effect on me as a kid. Although, I knew the riddle, the name of the ships, and that he found America, but that's it. After reading the articles I'm am a little shocked on how someone so selfish can have a day to call their own. I always thought of him as this great guy who had a wonderful life achievement. But sadly, there was other people who didn't get the credit that they deserve. In the article it states, that someone had said that they had seen a sign of an island. You were able to get a reward if you had seen land. Christopher Colombus had said that he had seen the land the night before. Not only does that sound ridiculous but why wouldn't of he had said something sooner since he was so interested in getting rewards? I now have a different perspective of Colombus Day. Instead of thinking of how great of a man he was to find America, I will now think of the other people who did before him but didn't get the credit.

    ReplyDelete
  23. When I was younger I was told Christopher Columbus was the hero who discovered America. I was told he was a great man and without him we wouldn't have America. We take a day off from school to celebrate him and everything he's done. Why? I mean I'm not complaining about having a day off from school because that’s fine with me but really? With all the information I know now I don’t understand why we celebrate a murderer and a liar. Christopher Columbus was a terrible person and there was nothing heroic about him at all. He took all the credit from Rodrigo for finding the Island. Also, he killed millions of Native Americans. He took Natives and held them captive as prisoners. He didn't even have a reason to, it wasn't right. Why should millions of Native Americans die for no reason? They were innocent people who meant no harm. Christopher Columbus was killing them for fun. I really do not see the point in putting these poor people through immense torture. Christopher Columbus was nowhere near a hero and I do not feel like anyone should be celebrating his accomplishments because he has none.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Columbus Day? Shouldn’t it be called Native American day. Christopher Columbus was an absolutely horrible human being who was only in it for the riches. Columbus committed so many horrible things that he doesn’t deserve a whole holiday dedicated to him. Killing many Native Americans, lying to the kings and queens of Spain, and much more. Who would call these actions so great to make a holiday out of it? The Native Americans were so nice in offering food, and gifts to Columbus when he first arrived and all he did was take advantage of them in so many ways. What kind of cruel person would do that? Taking women and kids and using them as sex slaves. And I don’t even understand who came up with Columba’s as being the discoverer of America. Native Americans were already on the land, walking and talking. It just doesn’t make since how they don’t acknowledge the Natives already being there before he came. Christopher Columbus definitely doesn’t deserve a holiday for all the things he did and because oh yeah, HE DIDN’T DISCOVER IT! Today you won’t find me celebrating this day, instead I’ll probably be sleeping in my bed so peacefully not even paying attention to Christopher’s Columbus’s crap.

    ReplyDelete
  25. “In 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue.” To be honest, I have never heard of this and was extremely confused when hearing it the first time in class. Nevertheless, when I heard
    “Columbus,” it brought back memories of lessons in Elementary and Middle School entirely about this one man. However back then, we certainly did not learn about the mistreatment and as Howard Zinn states, “genocide,” of the Native Americans. To say that I was surprised would be a lie because thinking back, history is filled with bloodshed. In order to conquer and obtain, sacrifices were made and people died. It has always been that way. Do you think the country that we live in now was won over in a discussion over a cup of tea. No. We fought, we killed, and we triumphed in the end. We also took land from the Native Americans as well. Although both were accomplished by killing, without it the present day would be completely different then it would be.
    Columbus is acknowledged as being the first to discover the Americas but he is also responsible for the killing and slavery of millions of Native Americans. So to have a day dedicated to man this man seems controversial. For me, I do not give a fly fadoodle about this day. All it really means to me is getting to sleep in and not come to school. Its just one of those holidays where the only reason you show appreciation for is because you get a day off.

    ReplyDelete
  26. In the eyes of an innocent child Christopher Columbus is a conqueror who sailed the ocean blue in 1492. To rest of the world he is the meaning of bloodshed, of tragedy, with the messes he has made with his bare hands. So maybe there is not a reason to celebrate but a reason to wonder the wrongs thing he set foot upon and made a glory of himself of doing nothing but bad. Columbus’s hands are burned deep with the color red showing the blood of the lives of people he caused to be slaughter. Columbus lied to his own king and queen to protect his own life causing the lives everyone around him to become endangered. To top it off he was certainly not the first person to discover the “Americas” as said right within the text it is clear the Native Americans were. Why else would Columbus try to keep them prisoner and claim the country to be his own. How could anyone believe him, when he brings back people from the land to show proof? The people are from the new land, making them the first to discover it. Does no one see the fault upon everyone’s beliefs toward this theory. Christopher Columbus certainly did not discover anything except his true nature that was brought out by his over confidence in making himself a hero in the eyes of people. Sadly it worked, but after reading this article no one can say the same for Christopher Columbus. He is a liar, a cheat, but how can anyone believe the truth if it is not being told nor heard. There is no one who speaks the truth of our history of Columbus. How would adults look when teaching their children or students of the man who killed thousands of people for his own advantage? If the truth is not discovered now, over time it will speak itself aloud…hopefully.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Alexis Sprenger
    10/14/13

    Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492. They didn’t mention to us that he murdered innocent people that tried to help him. As growing up we learned, sang, and colored pictures of him and his ships, but didn’t sing about the 3 million “Indians” he murdered. We all know Christopher Columbus as the hero that discovered America (but HE DIDN’T) and made new friends who shared Thanksgiving together. No. He is the one that murdered people, took them for granted, sent them out on a 3 month period to find gold and bring it back to him, and if they didn’t complete the mission their hands would get chopped off and they would bleed to death. As I read more I also discovered that he took credit for something that Rodrigo saw first. The moon shinning down on the white sands, the Caribbean. Christopher Columbus lied and said he saw it the night before. So now I know him as a liar and murderer. Great I can’t wait to tell my kids about the man that lied, murdered “Indians”, and discovered America. Yes honey that is Christopher Columbus, the one that you and I thought was such a great person. As humans we can’t do anything about it now, we can’t go back and stop him from murdering innocent people, we also can’t take off Columbus Day off the calendars. But that doesn’t mean we can’t cross off Columbus Day and change it to “The man who took “Indians” gold, murdered people, and took credit for “discovering America”.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I think we should have a day celebrating the founding of America, but I do not think we should have the holiday named after Christopher Columbus. It is celebrating all of the things that Christopher did including killing the Arawaks. I agree with Zinn,when he states that the children's history books make Columbus sound like he just went over to America on a heroic adventure and there was no bloodshed involved. That is probably why so many people think that he was a hero instead a mass murderer. Columbus Day should be named America Day, to recognize the natives that were already here as well as the explorers who came before Columbus.

    I think Flag Day is a worthless holiday, because it is just recognizing the American flag. That may be important for adults, but everyday in school,kids say the pledge of allegiance to the flag.

    ReplyDelete
  30. If you ask the average person who was Christopher Columbus and what’s he famous for, their answer would most likely be, “Oh, he’s the guy who discovered North America and met Native Americans,” after that, they won't go into much more detail. What they left off in their answer was that he was a man greedy for gold for his pals in Spain. And in order to get that gold he enslaved and wiped out a whole entire Native American tribe called the Arawaks. Christopher Columbus is obviously not a good person. He only cares about himself and he doesn’t care about other people. Christopher Columbus is the type to leave you to get caught to save his own ass. Plus, since Christopher Columbus was like this, he influenced his own people to treat the Native Americans like they were nothing. They killed them with no hesitation. Sometimes, they would even kill them just because they felt like it. Christopher Columbus is not someone who you want to look up to. However, this does not mean that we shouldn’t celebrate Columbus day. Christopher Columbus made a huge accomplishment in history. We don’t celebrate him, but we celebrate the founding of a new land.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Back in elementary school we learned that Christopher Columbus was an astonishing man. Well at least I did. Then, I started to grow up and learn that this so called brilliant geographer was a phony. We celebrate this holiday because he apparently found our land. There are two things wrong with that. One, he was not the first to approach the land. Two, he did not even mean to step foot here. These pages that I read sum up my whole argument. There were a couple things that I didn’t realize about this man. When I was young and believed everything I heard, I was taught that he sailed here and befriended the people he referred to as the Indians. Now what I found out was that if any were in his way, they would be killed. Now correct me if I am wrong but I certainly don’t think that is friendly. The one thing he did discover was that the world was round not flat and also how to be a jerk. This was the reason he made his big error on his journey. So why do we praise this horrible man? I wish he were here to listen to all of the crap we are giving him because he deserves it. I’m glad I was able to read this article because the image I was given in elementary school is ten times different then the one that is in my head now.

    ReplyDelete
  32. First off, I truly love how everyone writes a paragraph. All you said was, “Jot down some answers in the comment section below…” Nothing more, nothing less. But if everyone writes a paragraph, it would make me feel like, well “crap” if I don’t do the same, so here I go:
    Columbus Day can be thought of as a day that celebrates two things; the start to the new and upcoming world, or as a reminder of the sacrifice and hardship that the Native American population faced. If you asked me if we should celebrate Columbus Day, I would say yes. Not because of the “New World” that became our ignorant society, but because of the Native American struggle that we should engrave on the back of our head’s. Christopher Columbus was not the start of our life here on the Americas, because life was already here. We should remember those who faltered for today, Columbus Day, and let it be a lesson for many days to come.
    Being a man who speaks from a completely apathetic third-party, I could truly care less about the Holiday’s people celebrate. “To each his own” as my mom so irritatingly states. Every holiday is in one way or another “Worth Celebrating.”. Even little made up Holidays are worth celebrating just to spread some joy like, “kiss a soccer player day!!!” Any takers? Anyway, I don’t really know or celebrate many holidays. This coming from a guy who doesn’t even celebrate his own birthday. And for those reading this now… you already missed it. :)

    ReplyDelete
  33. In 1492 Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue. Pretty sure we all knew that part but what about the other side of him? The bad part that is. How would you feel if I came to your town and made you do my work; then I would kill you if you didn't do it? Obviously Mr. C did not care at all. I thought he was just the guy who sailed on the Mayflower to be friends with the Indians but hey I guess I thought wrong, and so did everyone else in elementary school. He was actually just a greedy man who only wanted all the gold. He just came into America and wiped out an entire tribe. Hes like the Hitler 1400’s. Contrastingly, without him life today probably would not be the way it is today.
    Other than the fact that we are off school on this holiday theres no point in having it. Why reward a horrible man with his own holiday? Its basically saying “Oh yeah lets give this man his own holiday because he was greedy and made people work for him.” I don’t know about you but that doesn't seem right to me at all. We celebrate the fact that someone found out the earth was round and not flat. I probably could have told you that to but you don't see me having my own holiday. At least I now know the truth about this horrid man and I will never think of him the same again.

    ReplyDelete
  34. ​ Christopher Columbus, the man who sailed the ocean blue in 1492. Seen as a great explorer in some, but a disease spreading, slave institutionalizing liar to others. Do I see Christopher Columbus celebrated as a holiday. No, I don’t think it should be celebrated as a holiday. Before I read the article and some pages of the book I didn’t really know that much about Christopher Columbus except for the famous line “ in 1492, Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue”. There are more bad things about Christopher Columbus than good. Columbus is a liar. Rodrigo was the first to discover the white sands of land and he would have gotten the yearly pension of 10,000 maravedis for life, but Columbus lied and say he discovered it first. Also, Columbus was the institutionalizer of Slavery and he started a genocide. Killing over 100,000 "Indians" in the process. That one moment when the two boys wee beheaded just for fun was sickening to my ears. Columbus treated these people like trash. He's the real trash in this whole situation. Wer'e celebrating about trash.

    ReplyDelete

  35. Columbus Day is a day that many now would have found offensive or completely and utterly worthless. However, this has been a holiday unofficially celebrated since, the eighteenth century and officially celebrated in the early twentieth century in most of the United States. It marks the day that Columbus had found the Americas and claimed to have made it to India and met the “Indians” when truly they were Native Americans. So, why do we in most states celebrate the day when the history books tell us that Columbus was not the best of men? Well the answer lies in history too, take a look at the time Columbus was alive. The way people lived, the way they thought, spoke, ate, drank and lived was much different to our own. By looking into the past we can see this and understand why it was once celebrated like how he was once celebrated as a hero. Yet, why do we do it now? One theory is that it’s become sort of like a tradition or habit in a way and everyone knows the saying “Old habits are hard to break. “Which, we can all agree that it holds a grain of salt to its saying. Now, are there any other useless holidays I’d like to get rid of to answer it’s not really cause even if personally there are no holidays I celebrate I still enjoy the days off and I’m sure the people here enjoy Columbus day off as well.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Everyone loves having that nice day off making it a great three day weekend. But is it really that, a great three day weekend, maybe two days but Columbus day is not something to be proud of. Celebrating Columbus Day is like saying that slave trading-which we had a civil war against-, killing innocent people-where in some states is punishable by death-, and just about any other physical crime that you could think of is all okay. The one thing that really tops off the whole Columbus thing is that he and his crew were rewarded for this. When I was much younger we used to glorify Christopher Columbus in school and want to be just like him-maybe it was because he was like famous. But teaching children about how good he is isn’t really a good thing; I don’t think that anyone thinks we need another person like him around. But I do think that we should still learn about him, but we don’t need a day off. We still learn about Hitler and how bad of a person he was, Columbus did a lot of the horrible things that Hitler did to the Jews, but just to the “Indians”.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.